Follies – Porchlight Music Theatre at Studebaker Theater – April 26, 2025

Porchlight’s Artistic Director, Michael Weber, once again put his impeccable casting abilities on display via a 21-person all-star ensemble that featured great individual performances and exquisite matching of characters, in particular the younger and not younger versions of Sally and Phyllis.

I don’t have room to mention everyone’s wonderful performance (and I do mean everyone), but if the audience reaction, in the way of loud, sustained applause and cheering, is a good measuring stick, then three solos are worth highlighting.

First, near the end of the first act, came Susie McMonagle chewing the scenery, in a good way, while belting I’m Still Here.

Next, in the second act, came Michelle Duffy’s rendition of Could I Leave You? Even as I was relishing her bravura performance, I couldn’t help but wonder whether it would be fun to then have Anthony Rapp, as her husband, enter singing If Ever I Would Leave You, from Camelot.

The third thunderous ovation came for Angela Ingersoll’s emotive performance of Losing My Mind. I was close enough to the stage to see tears coming down her cheeks, which she confirmed for me after the show.

I also would like to mention Stephen Wallem singing The God-Why-Don’t-You-Love-Me-Blues because I love the Blues, and hyphens, and because Wallem’s turn reminded me of John C. Reilly, and that’s a good thing.

Finally a shout out to Teagan Earley, whose sophisticated shoulder moves during her dancing caught my attention. It’s the little things.

Oh, and the 12-piece band was terrific.

New Faces Sing Broadway 1960 (Porchlight Music Theatre) – The Rhapsody Theater – September 30, 2025

The government may have shut down, but I still get out and Porchlight Music Theatre still puts on entertaining shows.

It was my first time at The Rhapsody Theater (including under its previous incarnation as the Mayne Stage), although I did see the owner, Dr. Ricardo T. Rosenkranz, perform his magic act, and get called up on stage by him, in 2016 at the now-defunct Royal George Cabaret.

Michael Weber, the Porchlight Artistic Director, also calls people up to the stage, as part of the New Faces programs, to ask them often impossibly-difficult Broadway trivia questions, from which he seems to derive great satisfaction, all in good fun.

But the real entertainment comes from the performances by the young cast (introduced by long-time Chicago area performer and director Johanna McKenzie Miller, who also treated us to a song), some of whom may go on to great things in the theater, as suggested by Weber when he mentioned three recent graduates of the 10-year-old New Faces program who are now making national names for themselves.

This incarnation of New Faces took me down memory lane, as one of the featured shows, the Lucille Ball star-driven vehicle Wildcat, was inexplicably the first Broadway musical album I ever heard. As I listened to Lisa Buhelos and Kaitlin Feely sing Hey Look Me Over, I reflected on how much better singers they were than Ball.

1960 produced some memorable shows, and they were represented, but Weber also likes to extract songs from less-than-successful productions, such as Christine, which probably would have done better had it been based on the Stephen King story of the same name, rather than a book by Hilda Werhner (who?), closing after 12 performances.

The evening ended on a high note, actually two, the one concluding Somewhere from West Side Story, and the one confirming my earlier decision to park on the street, as I observed the long line of people trying to retrieve their vehicles from the valet-only, practically inaccessible, paltry parking lot.