The movie Chicago is one of my favorites, and will remain so, but it will never be the same after seeing, for the first time, a live production of the musical. In particular, this production may be the best show I’ve ever seen (admittedly, recency bias could be in play). I guess my reaction shouldn’t be totally surprising given how long the musical has been a mainstay in the American theater pantheon. Interestingly, the six somewhat lukewarm reviews currently linked to on TheatreinChicago are all in regard to a 2023 production. That’s unfair. Disregard them.
The first thing you notice, of course, are all the jazz hands. And they never let up, but all the movement is hypnotic. The positions, the subtleties, the grace and the athleticism by all the dancers is unforgettable.
When Claire Marshall, as Velma Kelly, opens the show with All That Jazz, the reaction is “wow.” But then Ellie Roddy, as Roxie Hart, gives us her Funny Honey, another “wow,” and the competition between the characters and the actors as to who should be the center of attention is off and running.
There isn’t a moment when the show drags. The supporting players, most prominently Max Cervantes (billy Flynn), Marc Christopher (Amos Hart), Illeana Kirven ((Mama Morton) and J. Clanton (Mary Sunshine) are all wonderful. And I would have paid just to hear the band.